CHAIRMAN: DR. KHALID BIN THANI AL THANI
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF: PROF. KHALID MUBARAK AL-SHAFI

Default / Miscellaneous

Egyptians protest after draft statute okayed

Published: 01 Dec 2012 - 01:19 am | Last Updated: 05 Feb 2022 - 09:37 pm


A general view of protesters chanting anti-government slogans at Tahrir Square in Cairo yesterday. 
 

CAIRO: Tens of thousands of Egyptians protested against President Mohammed Mursi yesterday after an Islamist-led assembly raced through approval of a new constitution in a bid to end a crisis over the Islamist leader’s newly expanded powers.

“The people want to bring down the regime,” they chanted in Tahrir Square, echoing the chants that rang out in the same place less than two years ago and brought down Hosni Mubarak.

Mursi said a decree halting court challenges to his decisions, which sparked eight days of protests and violence by Egyptians calling him a new dictator, was “for an exceptional stage” and aimed to speed up the democratic transition.

“It will end as soon as the people vote on a constitution,” he told state television while the constituent assembly was still voting on a draft, which the Islamists say reflects Egypt’s new freedoms. “There is no place for dictatorship.”

But the opposition cried foul. Liberals, leftists, Christians, more moderate Muslims and others had withdrawn from the assembly, saying their voices were not being heard.

Even in the mosque where Mursi said Friday prayers some opponents chanted “Mursi: void” before sympathisers surrounded him shouting in support, journalists and a security source said.

Tens of thousands gathered across the country, filling Tahrir Square and hitting the streets in Alexandria and other cities, responding to opposition calls for a big turnout. Rival demonstrators clashed after dark in Alexandria and the Nile Delta town of Al Mahala Al Kobra, some hurling rocks in anger.

An opposition leaflet distributed on Tahrir urged protesters in Cairo to stay overnight before today’s rallies by Islamists; the Muslim Brotherhood and its allies said they would avoid the square during their demonstrations backing Mursi.

The disparate opposition, which has struggled to compete with well-organised Islamists, has been drawn together and reinvigorated by the crisis. Tens of thousands had also protested on Tuesday, showing the breadth of public anger.

But Islamists have a potent political machine and the United States has looked on warily at the rising power of a group it once kept at arms length now ruling a nation that has a peace treaty with Israel and is at the heart of the Arab Spring.

Protesters said they would push for a ‘no’ vote in a constitutional referendum, which could happen as early as mid-December. If the new basic law were approved, it would immediately cancel the president’s decree.

“We fundamentally reject the referendum and constituent assembly because the assembly does not represent all sections of society,” said Sayed El Erian, 43, a protester in Tahrir and member of a party set up by opposition figure Mohamed ElBaradei.

ElBaradei said in a statement that the constitution had “lost legitimacy” and called for ending the polarisation of Egypt. The plebiscite on the constitution is a gamble based on the Islamists’ belief they can mobilise voters again after winning every election held since Mubarak was toppled in February 2011.

Despite the big numbers opposed to him, Mursi can count on backing from the disciplined Brotherhood and Islamist allies, as well as many Egyptians who are simply exhausted by the turmoil. “He just wants us to move on and not waste time in conflicts,” said 33-year-old Cairo shopkeeper Abdel Nasser Marie. “Give the man a chance and Egypt a break.”

But Mursi needs the cooperation of judges to oversee the vote, and many have been angered by a decree from Mursi they said undermined the judiciary. Some judges are on strike.

The assembly concluded the vote after a 19-hour session, faster than many expected, approving all 234 articles of the draft, covering  presidential powers, the status of Islam, the military’s role and human rights.

It introduces a presidential term limit of eight years - Mubarak served for 30. It also bring in a degree of civilian oversight over the military - though not enough for critics.

An Egyptian official said Mursi was expected to approve the document today and then has 15 days to hold a referendum. “This is a revolutionary constitution,” said Hossam El Gheriyani, head of the assembly, urging members to campaign for the new constitution across Egypt, after the all-night session.

Critics argue it is an attempt to rush through a draft they say has been hijacked by the Muslim Brotherhood, which backed Mursi for president in a June election, and its Islamist allies.

Two people have been killed and hundreds injured in protests since the decree was announced on November 22, deepening the divide between the newly empowered Islamists and their critics.

Seeking to placate opponents, Mursi welcomed criticism but said there was no place for violence. “I am very happy that Egypt has real political opposition,” he told state television.

He said Egypt needed to attract investors and tourists. The crisis threatens to derail a fragile economic recovery after two years of turmoil. Egypt is waiting for the International Monetary Fund to finalise a $4.8bn loan to help it out.

An alliance of opposition groups pledged to keep up protests and said broader civil disobedience was possible to fight what it described as an attempt to “kidnap Egypt from its people”.

Several independent newspapers said they would not publish on Tuesday in protest. One of the papers also said three private satellite channels would halt broadcasts on Wednesday.

The draft injects new Islamic references into Egypt’s system of government but keeps in place an article defining “the principles of sharia” as the main source of legislation - the same phrase found in the previous constitution.

The president can declare war with parliament’s approval, but only after consulting a national defence council with a heavy military and security membership. That was not in the old constitution, used when Egypt was ruled by ex-military men.

Reuters


Key articles in draft charter

CAIRO: Egypt’s draft constitution, approved in a marathon session that ended yesterday morning and that was boycotted by liberals and Christians, has drawn condemnation from rights groups. The following are some of the charters key provisions:

Article 2: “Islam is the state religion, and Arabic its official language, and the principles of Islamic law its primary source of legislation.”

This article is taken from the constitution suspended after president Hosni Mubarak’s overthrow in early 2011, and its vague formulation is uncontroversial for most Egyptians. An added provision narrows the “principles” to the rulings and tenets of Sunni Muslim jurisprudence, to which Christian churches and liberals object.

Article 11: “The state and society will look after morality and public order, and standards of religious values and education.” Rights activists say this clause, and another that tasks police with preserving public “morality,” codifies police intervention in what may be considered un-Islamic conduct.

Article 31: “Dignity is the right of every human; society and the state undertake its protection, and insulting or slandering a human is not allowed.” Human Rights Watch Egypt director Heba Morayef says this opens to door to censorship of political criticism deemed “insulting.”

Article 33: “Citizens are equal before the law in rights and public obligations, with no discrimination among them.” 

Article 43: “Freedom of belief is safeguarded. The state guarantees freedom of performing religious rites, and establishing houses of worship, for heavenly religions.” This article, rights activists say, limits religious freedoms to followers of Islam, Christianity and Judaism. 

Article 133: The provision limits the democratically elected president to two four-year terms. Mubarak ruled continuously since 1981.

Article 195: “The minister of defence is the commander of the armed forces and is appointed from its officers.” 

Article 197: Establishes a military general dominated council led by the president that discusses the military budget and must be consulted on laws pertaining to the military. Critics say this essentially safeguards army privileges enjoyed under Mubarak.

Article 198: This provision allows the trial of civilians before military courts only “for crimes that harm the armed forces.” Rights groups had wanted a complete ban on military trials for civilians.

AFP